The Best Value Used Car List for 2021
Is it time for you to buy a used car? If so, you’ve come to the right place. McCluskey Chevrolet delivers the world’s best car shopping experience at our dealership and online. This is made better with a patented nationwide search tool that can find you the perfect vehicle within 24 hours. With this tool and our expansive inventory in Cincinnati, Ohio, we are able to provide buyers with the best value used cars. We sell all makes and models in our used vehicle inventory, and they all come with a Carfax Guaranteed Clean Vehicle History Report, so you are guaranteed a great model. In addition, at McCluskey Chevy, we provide every buyer with a lifetime mechanical warranty on their used vehicle at no charge.
When you come to McCluskey Chevy to shop for a used vehicle, we want you to have access to a list of vehicles rated for the best value. That’s why we assembled a list of options in every category, so buyers searching for used vehicles in 2021 can shop with the best value in mind. Each vehicle selected was chosen according to its reliability, how it holds value, and its high safety ratings.
Honda has a great record for producing reliable, long-lasting vehicles, and the Honda Accord is one of the best-selling midsize sedans in the country. More recent designs are sporty and sleek, with a roomy interior that incorporates soft-touch materials for a classy appeal. Rear seat legroom and trunk space are generous and above average for the segment. Hybrid models have been available since 2014—including plug-in hybrids—for improved fuel economy, though the Accord already gets good mileage with fuel-sipping engines. Going back to 2016 models, buyers can expect Honda Sensing driver-assisted safety features to be standard equipment, and models dating back to 2010 could have Bluetooth connectivity.
One of the winners of the 2018 "Most Dependable" award given by J.D. Power was the 2015 Chevy Malibu. This award is given to a vehicle when it proves itself after three years of ownership, and the Malibu has been a top-selling midsize sedan in the segment for many years. The Malibu has a smart exterior design with a comfortable and roomy interior which makes it a perfect vehicle for daily commutes or long drives. With high safety ratings and affordable pricing, this midsize sedan fits into any budget as a no-brainer. Redesigns in 2013 and 2016 shift both styling and features, making Chevy MyLink standard on most trims in 2016 as part of the infotainment features. Like Honda, driver-assisted safety features were most prevalent starting in 2016.
When you need a full-size SUV that does it all, you want a Chevy Tahoe. Take the whole team to practice with seating for up to nine passengers in the luxuriously comfortable interior, or take your extended family on a vacation with your boat or camper in tow. Powerful engines make the Tahoe a versatile SUV that can haul and tow like a truck but pampers your passengers with a plush interior. Entertainment options will vary across the years, though some models will feature rear-seat entertainment systems, and OnStar connectivity can be found in models going back to 2014. The Tahoe has been a best-seller year after year due to its reliability and durability meshed with a long list of conveniences and features.
Another luxurious full-size SUV that holds its value is the Lincoln Navigator. Like the Tahoe, the Navigator is a truck-based SUV that can tow and haul heavy loads—including up to eight passengers—but does so with a quality, upscale interior that delivers luxury, which remains a high-selling favorite in the class. Going back to 2012, the Navigator featured power-folding third-row seats, and all the way back in 1999, Navigators offered hands-free cell phone options. Safety features like reverse sensors were available in 2000, and backup cameras were standard in 2009. Every year of the Navigator brings a high-tech set of features combined with a smooth ride quality buyers continue to love.

Families in need of the ultimate in convenience vehicles are sure to be delighted by the Honda Odyssey. Few other minivans deliver handling so similar to the feel of a car with so much space on the inside. Known for its reliability, intelligent design, and satisfying V6 engine, the Odyssey has been a best-seller in the class for many years with an excellent safety record. Whether it’s the versatile cargo area with fold-flat seats, the volume for both passengers and cargo, or the comfort of the cabin with its supportive and roomy seating for seven or eight, Honda knows how to keep buyers coming back for more. 2013 models started featuring standard hands-free phone connectivity and rearview cameras, though rear-seat entertainment has been available since 2000. The handy sliding doors on each side of the Odyssey make it simple for exit and entry, especially with children, and it can be had with all-wheel drive and traction control for winter weather.
Much like the Honda Odyssey, the Toyota Sienna is built with plenty of tech and convenience features while also wrapping it in a package of safety. Interior space and comfort are what you would expect in a minivan of Toyota’s caliber and quality while also delivering a satisfying driving experience that is responsive for its size. Engine types vary year to year, with either a four-cylinder or V6 under the hood, though in 2004, it began offering all-wheel drive. That same year Toyota began selling fold-flat rear seats, a feature Honda offered in every model year. Rear-seat entertainment became available in 2000, and in 2005 it offered sliding rear doors. By 2008, Bluetooth was standard on all trims.
In 2018, JD Power awarded the Chevy Silverado 1500 with the Dependability Award, which will come as no surprise to those who have owned the Silverado, and is one of the brand’s best-selling vehicles. This is a machine built for hard work, but it can also get out to play. Trucks of top-selling brands tend to be the most customizable of vehicles on the market, and varying cab and bed sizes will accompany a vast array of trim levels that offer a wide variety of features. Basic work trucks often come with easy-to-clean vinyl seats and smaller cabs, while upper trims are decked with luxurious leather upholstery and premium audio systems that can seat up to six. Towing and hauling are readily accommodated if towing assemblies are installed, and the Silverado models with tow-haul mode and other trailering technology make towing a simple affair. The Silverado has been produced since 2000 and is available as either rear-wheel or four-wheel drive.
Like the Chevy Silverado, the Toyota Tundra is a best-selling truck in its class and has been in production since 2000. This is a truck often suited to those who need a work vehicle, particularly if you wear a lot of gear because the seating accommodates it by design in certain trims. Like most trucks, the Tundra comes in a dizzying array of configurations, with several cab and bed sizes available in a large number of trims. Toyota is known for its safety features which are incorporated into every vehicle, and the Tundra is no different. The brand thoughtfully includes convenience and tech features in every trim that tune into the intended purpose of the truck, and towing and hauling are as simple with the Tundra as with any of the top-selling brands. Regular cabs were discontinued in 2014, but Bluetooth was made standard. Rear-wheel drive is standard, with the option for four-wheel drive.

Not all buyers who want a truck need a full-size model, and one of the best-selling midsize trucks is the Toyota Tacoma. As is true across the brand, Toyota delivers a reliable, safe truck in a size that still works hard for a living without being so large. Even though the Tacoma is powered by a four-cylinder engine, it still has the capability to tow and haul. In addition, this is a truck favored by off-road enthusiasts due to its incredible agility. Unlike the full-size trucks, the midsize segment doesn’t have the same variety of options for cab and bed volume, but the Tacoma still has choices available. Both rear-wheel and four-wheel drive are available, and fuel efficiency is far better than a larger truck.
Another best-seller in the midsize truck segment is the Honda Ridgeline, which also happens to be a favorite of off-roading fans. In 2017, the Ridgeline received the J.D. Power award for dependability, which comes as no surprise with the Honda brand's reputation. Unlike the Tacoma, the Ridgeline is constructed on a unibody frame which is more typical of smaller SUVs or cars, and it comes standard with front-wheel drive. The option to add four-wheel drive is available, though the Ridgeline is aimed at being a better daily driver than most other trucks due to lower fuel consumption and better performance on paved roads. Make no mistake: the Ridgeline can still haul in the bed and tow light trailers, and it has high safety ratings as well as being generous with technology. 2017 is the most recent redesign, and before that, a number of significant upgrades were added in 2012.
For many years, the Chevy Equinox has held a fond place in the hearts of SUV lovers. It continues to be a top seller for Chevy, and in 2019 it won the JD Power award for reliability. With seating for five, this small SUV still boasts about 30 cubic feet of cargo space in the rear cargo area and more than double that when the seats are folded down. The stylish exterior often draws buyers to its sporty yet shapely appearance and provides a comfortable and feature-laden interior sure to please modern lifestyles. The earliest models were produced in 2005, and has always come standard with front-wheel drive. The option to add all-wheel drive makes this crossover capable in snowy climates and has come with a number of engine choices over the years. In 2007, StabiliTrak came standard on all models, and 2012 models introduced seven-inch touchscreens.
Once again, Honda claims another spot at the best-selling table with the Honda CR-V, a small crossover with a big reputation for reliability. The CR-V has been available in the States since 1997, introduced only as a four-wheel drive SUV. Since then, Honda changed the drivetrain to standard front-wheel drive and optional all-wheel drive. Despite being considered small, the CR-V offers almost 40 cubic feet in the rear cargo area, which almost doubles when the seats are folded. Known for excellent handling and safety, the CR-V continues to be a hit with buyers who want a sturdy daily driver that gets good fuel efficiency for a low price. Now in its fourth generation, the most recent redesign was in 2017. Across the years, the CR-V is known for being one of the roomiest of its segment and typically sports a comfortable and attractive interior.

When the Kia Soul first hit the market in 2010, it made waves as a funky, spirited SUV which is considered a car-based crossover hatchback. Despite its small size, the rear cargo area has almost 25 cubic feet that expands to between 50-60 cubic feet when the back seats are down. It is considered compact, but the height of the cabin allows for tall adults to sit quite comfortably inside. The smaller size does help on fuel efficiency, and it handles well, even if the stiff suspension may deliver a somewhat bumpy ride. From the earliest models, the Soul came with a push-button start, and in 2013 all models came standard with Bluetooth. Since the beginning, the Soul has been a favorite of younger drivers who love the fun paint color options, modern features, and styling.
A brand known for making peppy vehicles is Mazda, and the Mazda3 hatchback is no exception to the rule. While the Mazda3 is incredibly fun to drive, it also scores high in reliability ratings. Buyers love the spunky energy of this little powerhouse, particularly once the 2007 models were offered with a sport-tuned suspension and turbocharged engine for improved performance. If you want a compact car for daily commutes that offers space in the trunk for supplies, the Mazda 3 will make that commute a lot more fun. 2014 and 2019 were recent years for redesigns which increased both performance and tech features, some of which boosted Mazda’s sales to make the Mazda 3 its fastest-selling vehicle in 2019. The Mazda 3 has featured LED tail lights since 2007, and in 2009 roof spoilers were added. Upper trim 2010 models had rain-sensing wipers, and 2014 saw the introduction of Mazda’s fastback design.
Buying a used car from most dealerships is likely to be a stress-inducing experience, but McCluskey Chevy has put the fun back into car shopping. When you search our online inventory, you’re getting access to our nationwide search that finds the best vehicles at the lowest prices, and you have access 24 hours a day, seven days a week. As soon as you find a vehicle you love, you also have instant access to our online credit approval process, which will guarantee you a loan, even if you have bad or no credit.
Once you buy your vehicle, McCluskey can deliver it to you! Whether you want it in your home driveway or brought to you at work, we will bring it to you in pristine condition. We offer the world’s best service, and we stand by our promise to make your experience the best you’ve ever had at a dealership. After we deliver your vehicle or you come to us and drive it home, our skilled technicians will always be there for you to keep your vehicle maintained for top performance as long as you own your car. We provide Cincinnati with the best full-line body shop that treats your vehicle to the best oil change and service.
Rest easy knowing your vehicle purchased from McCluskey Chevy is protected with the Tri-State’s Exclusive Lifetime Mechanical Protection program, so you never have to worry about the cost of repairs covered by this guarantee. Because we want to make maintaining your vehicle as easy as possible, our service center is open seven days a week, with hours extended to 3 AM. No matter what your work schedule is, we are certain you can find a good time to enjoy the quality service we offer.