Parental Guidance: Is the Chevy Equinox More Family-Friendly Than the Nissan Rogue?

January 26th, 2024 by

A red 2024 Chevy Equinox RS is shown parked near a store after a 2024 Chevy Equinox vs 2024 Nissan Rogue comparison.

Being a parent is one of the most challenging roles that anyone can assume. Finding a vehicle that is reliable, safe, and family-friendly can sometimes seem just as challenging, especially with all the new models arriving on the market every year. Parents searching for a vehicle have many factors to consider: they need something affordable and safe that can also facilitate their younger, shorter passengers’ finicky and sometimes high expectations. Finding the right features to keep them entertained on road trips is an essential part of vehicle shopping.

One of the most family-friendly vehicles on the market is the Chevy Equinox. As the second-best-selling model in Chevy’s fleet, its popularity certainly speaks for itself as something parents can trust. Also popular is the Nissan Rogue, praised for its stylish charm and exceptional fuel economy. Both of these vehicles stand to offer a family-friendly experience, so let’s compare the two to determine a definitive answer as to which one is better. In the end, between the 2024 Chevy Equinox vs 2024 Nissan Rogue, the real winner will be the parent in search of their next great carryall.

Would You Prefer Better Value or More Flair?

Let’s cut right to the chase: one of the discernable differences between these vehicles is their value—what you get for your money. Any parent knows the importance of stretching a dollar. Let’s begin with the upfront costs… The 2024 Nissan Rogue has a starting MSRP of $29,685, which is affordable and less than some of its competitors, such as comparable offerings from Honda, Mazda, Kia, and Hyundai.[a] However, the Equinox is a much more affordable vehicle with a starting price of $26,600.[a]

This is a huge difference, and every bit counts for the parent keen on managing their expenses. While Nissan strives to pad the Rogue with tons of aesthetic upgrades, the Equinox places more emphasis on practicality, which is what most budget-conscious drivers gravitate toward. Both of these models have four trim levels, and while the differences between prices of Equinox trims climb gradually, the Rogue’s trims escalate in price rather steeply.

In It for the Long Haul

Both the Nissan Rogue and Chevy Equinox come with standard FWD, which is perfect for city-driving conditions. But what if the roads are less manageable or the weather becomes unpredictable? Both cars have an option for such situations: AWD. This is perfect for families living in unpredictable climates or those who enjoy an adventure away from civilization.

When towing something like a camper or trailer, the Chevy Equinox is the better option as it can tow up to 3,500 lbs, whereas the Nissan Rogue can only tow up to 1,500 lbs when properly equipped. If you’re a parent who wants to teach their children about adventure, the Chevy Equinox is the ideal choice for you.

A red 2024 Nissan Rogue is shown driving on a city street.

The Driving Experience

Looking at the performance of both vehicles is somewhat akin to comparing apples and oranges. Both have smaller engines designed for practicality and fuel efficiency, but one notable difference between them is their handling. The Equinox has been praised for its smooth ride and responsive handling, which is more like a sedan than an SUV, and while the Rogue is also easy to drive, some reviews have noted that the driving experience can be dull.

Repairs and Insurance

Upfront pricing is one thing, but there are a number of costs behind owning a vehicle. It’s important for modern parents to consider the cost of insurance premiums and maintenance when purchasing a car. Fuel economy can vary depending on driving habits and fuel prices, too, so to help you make an informed decision, let’s examine the costs of insurance and repairs to ensure they fit comfortably within your budget.

Neither vehicle exceeds the threshold of $1,000 in annual repair costs until their seventh year on the road. This is better than the industry average and ensures that you’ll be able to get quite a bit out of either model. The rate of insurance for both vehicles is also very close to one another, as it’s in the average ballpark of $1,500 a year. Remember that premiums vary on the age and record of different drivers, among other criteria, and depending on the carrier you choose.

Comfort & Family-Oriented Features

Now, let’s compare these models’ interiors and determine which one is more suitable for parents, kids, and family road trips. Earlier, we mentioned that the Equinox is practical while the Rogue is stylish, and this is evident in their interiors. The Rogue’s cabin resembles the Altima sedan, but appearances can be deceiving because the Rogue offers a subpar driving experience. Despite having a turbocharged three-cylinder engine, it is not suitable for the urban or suburban family as it corners poorly. Also, to make a commute enjoyable, more money needs to be spent on additional features.

If the Rogue’s interior is meant to look like a sedan, then the Equinox is built to handle like one. This has been one of the consistent observations from those who take this vehicle on a test drive. Despite being an SUV, the Equinox is easy to maneuver around city limits and certainly has no issue doing so. Its interior isn’t exactly on par with a luxury sedan, but it’s far from spartan.

The Equinox and Rogue’s infotainment systems are both compatible with Apple and Android products and have a user-friendly touchscreen to access those features that’ll enhance their experience on the road. At the time of this writing, collision testing on the 2024 Nissan Rogue has not been conducted, but the same can’t be said for the Chevy Equinox, which already received a five-star safety rating from the NHTSA. This is objective testing that’s mandated by the government and made accessible to consumers everywhere.

One feature that the Equinox has that’s absent on the Rogue is precisely what parents will look for regarding their younger drivers—and that’s GM’s Teen Driver mode, which comes standard on the 2024 Equinox. This tool has a virtual report card, which will help ensure that your teenager subscribes to responsible driving habits. Teen Driver mode also allows you to limit items like speed and stereo volume, ensuring they’re being responsible when behind the wheel. This is easily one of the greatest tools to come along in some time, and all parents can use this to their advantage.

A close-up of a Equinox badge on the tailgate of a red 2024 Chevy Equinox is shown.

The 2024 Equinox Awaits at McCluskey Chevrolet

Today’s comparison has shown two unique vehicles that are capable of providing parents with affordable, effective transportation. Both can be purchased, maintained, and insured for a reasonable rate, which is what families look for in their vehicles. Parents are among the choosiest of drivers and expect the best out of every investment—and while this race was tough, the Chevy Equinox is by far the superior choice.

Aside from being the more affordable option, the Equinox is an effective vehicle that doesn’t need to bother with bells and whistles to prove itself worthwhile. Its strong safety rating and palpable comfort features make it an ideal choice for the modern parent. From the Equinox to the rest of the Chevy fleet, you’ll find the best selection here at McCluskey Chevrolet; we’ve got models that drivers from all walks of life will thoroughly enjoy.


 

[a] MSRP may change without notice. See dealer for complete details.